BlogPolicing
March 31, 2011

The Numbers Don’t Lie: NYPD Stop-and-Frisk Is About Race, Not Crime-Fighting

Stop & Frisk
Stop and Frisk

In March, the New York Police Department released its stop-and-frisk numbers for 2010, and they are quite alarming. The total number of stops conducted by NYPD officers increased for a third year in a row, to more than 600,000, an all-time record and a more than 600% increase since 2002, the first year of the Michael Bloomberg – Ray Kelly administration.

Even more disturbing are the stats on whom and where the police are stopping-and-frisking. More than 85% of those stopped-and-frisked last year were Black or Latino, even though those two groups together make up only around 50% of New York City’s population, and the ten precincts with the greatest numbers of stops all have majority Black and/or Latino populations, including three in Central Brooklyn: the 73rd in Brownsville, the 75th in Crown Heights/East New York, and the 79th in Bed-Stuy. Meanwhile, for most of the past decade, crime has continued to drop or stay flat both Citywide and in communities of color in particular.

The NYPD offers several explanations for these disturbing stop-and-frisk numbers, none of which is convincing. First, they claim that the racial disparities in the stop-and frisk data match the racial demographics of violent criminal suspects, 90% of whom the NYPD says are Black or Latino. But this 90% figure is inaccurate because it only represents those violent crimes where the race of the suspect is known, while a study conducted last fall by Professor Jeffrey Fagan of Columbia University found that suspect race is actually unknown in almost half of all violent crimes reported to the NYPD. (A copy of Professor Fagan’s study is available here.)

So in reality, the percentage of violent crimes known to have been committed by Black and Latino suspects is under 50%. More importantly, less than 15 % of all stops-and-frisks are made on suspicion of a violent crime, while the vast majority of stops are made on suspicion of property, quality of life, and non-violent drug offenses. The race of violent criminal suspects therefore tells us little to nothing about the racial disparities in stop-and-frisk.

The NYPD also says that it concentrates its stop-and-frisk activity in the highest-crime areas of the City, which “just happen” to have high Black and/or Latino populations. Again, the data tells a different story. In his analysis of six-years worth of NYPD stop-and-frisk and crime data, Professor Fagan found that, even after controlling for higher crime rates and more police officers deployed in certain precincts, the higher the Black and/or Latino population in a precinct, the more stop-and-frisk activity in that precinct. Professor Fagan also found that Black and Latino pedestrians were more likely than Whites to be stopped-and-frisked even in low-crime, majority White precincts.

As for the NYPD’s claims that stop-and-frisk has reduced crime and made the City safer, neither the NYPD’s own data nor years of social science research support this conclusion. Only about 1 out of every 10 stops-and-frisks uncover evidence of a crime, and illegal weapons are only recovered in a little more than 1% of the stops. In addition, a 2004 study by the National Research Council found no reliable empirical evidence linking aggressive use of street-level policing tactics like stop-and-frisk with crime reduction. In fact, the research and common sense suggest just the opposite.

Overly-aggressive and racially biased stops-and-frisks increase fear and distrust of the police in communities of color and therefore make these communities less, not more, likely to cooperate with police in fighting crime. Moreover, criminologists and policing experts have been warning for years that citizens tend not to comply with laws they believe are being enforced against them in an arbitrary and discriminatory way.

In short, the data and research clearly show what we at the Center for Constitutional Rights (CCR) and others in the civil rights and police accountability movements have known for years: The NYPD’s stop-and-frisk strategy is about race, not crime-fighting. It’s time for the NYPD to put an end to these shameful, illegal, and ineffective practices. Unfortunately, the last decade has taught us that the NYPD won’t to do so on its own. These long-overdue changes will only happen if civil rights and police accountability advocates, City, state, and federal government officials and, most importantly, members of the communities most impacted by stop-and-frisk, make an effort to hold the NYPD’s feet to the fire.

The CCR is pushing for some simple fixes which the NYPD could implement tomorrow, and which would have a huge effect.  First, transfer the authority to prosecute all susbtantiated civilian complaints of police misconduct (including but not limited to complaints of improper stops-and-frisks) from the police dept itself to the Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB). The CCRB has the capacity to do this, and police dept has shown for many years that it is unwilling and/or unable to hold officers accountable for violating people’s rights.

Also, the Civil Rights Division of the US Dept of Justice should investigate the stop-and-frisk practices of the NYPD for civil rights violations.  The DOJ should come up with a list of policy changes that it requires the NYPD to make, or face a lawsuit. Similar investigations were done by the DOJ in Cincinatti, Los Angeles and most recently New Orleans. In the first two cities, the investigations ultimately led to signifcant reforms in those cities’ police departments, and New Orleans is now in the process of implementing several of the DOJ’s recommendations as well.

Here at CCR, we are using both litigation and grassroots education and advocacy strategies to make these sorts of reforms happen. To find out more about our work and how to get involved, please visit us here.

Some more reading on the subject from the BMC:

A Few Blocks, 4 years, and 52,000 Police Stops

The NYPD Tapes: Inside Bed-Stuy’s 81st Precinct

NYPD Stop-and-frisk policy in public housing leads to $150K in settlements

About this author

Marly Pierre-Louis

Marly is a graduate student studying Urban Planning at Hunter College and a full time mommy to BMC’s junior employee, Sekani. Prior to coming to BMC, Marly served as the Social Media Marketing intern for PCI Media Impact and a member of the Coordinating Committee for the Malcolm X Grassroots MovementShe has a background in advocacy and social justice work and has done communications work for PCI Media Impact and Malcolm X Grassroots Movement. A love of international travel coupled with a slight scatterbrain has caused Marly to lose 4 passports within 4 years. She is now on a Department of State red list.

0 comments

There are no comments for this post yet.

Be the first to comment. Click here.

Blog
 
Originally written for Gawker . With Brooklyn’s spring thaw in full effect,...
 
Originally written for  EBONY.com   Fifteen-year-old Veralyn would have chuckled at the...
 
Both police harassment and gendered & sexualized street harassment contribute to...
 
Wednesday’s New York Times featured an article announcing the results of...
 
There’s been no shortage of eloquent commentary and reflection on the...
 
The latest indictment of the Department of Education’s management of failing...
 
For the last year and a half I have been BMC’s...
 
As a longtime resident of Bedford-Stuyvesant, who directly experienced stop-and-frisk abuses...
 
After a passionate debate a few days before the official vote...
 
Listen to Manny W. talk about how a constant police presence...
 
As I approached the corner of Throop Avenue and Van Buren...
 
January inaugurations are typically a time to look forward. Although it’s...
 
On July 21st 2013 Kyam Livingston, a 37 year old African...
 
Listen to Ricky S. talk about the misplaced priorities of the...
 
People have the right to know what they’re eating – particularly...
 
Much of the discourse around gentrification centers on the...
 
BMC’s Anti-Street Harassment Working Group occupied Potomac Playground  (on Tompkins between Halsey & Macon) to listen...
 
I’ve been thinking more and more about my grandma lately as...
 
On July 28th, the Brooklyn Movement Center, in partnership with the...
 
Raise your hand if you’re jaded by elections. You should be....
 
Black and brown people deserve the right to LIFE, liberty and...
 
“Can I help you with those bags, ma?” said the man...
 
The moment I found out about the verdict, the room changed....
 
Why a spectrum? BMC’s Anti-Street Harassment Working Group is working on...
 
Few people consider voting subversive activity. In fact, we think of...
 
  The race to represent District 36 in the NYC Council...
 
“Crack is wack!” Not sure if that enlightening epiphany by the...
 
By Debjani Roy, Hollaback! When it comes to combating street harassment,...
 
It has come to this: We want you to take over...
 
Listen to Malcolm S. talk about the various constitutional violations inherent...
 
By Tanay Warerkar On a recent morning while riding the subway...
 
David Ushery sits down with Marly Pierre-Louis and Anthonine Pierre from...
 
By Kat Noel It was on a trip to the neighborhood...
 
“I said she looks nice today. What’s wrong with that? Why...
 
By Paul DeBenedetto BEDFORD-STUYVESANT — On a recent morning, on her way...
 
While jogging down the street a few years ago, I suddenly...
 
Marc K. believes the NYPD are directly targeting communities of color....
 
Listen to Maya S. talk about how she feels paranoid and...
 
It’s not every day that our Executive Director turns…um…30! Rather than...
 
Join Mom’s Rising on Saturday, March 2 in NYC for an inspirational gathering...
 
Listen to Michael talk about the consequences of taking a plea...
 
Write a 100 page annual report that no one will read?...
 
What does being a citizen mean to you? To be able...
 
Listen to Miles K. talk about how angry it made him...
 
In this episode of “On The Block”, BMC sits with Chelsea...
 
Listen to Milton P. talk about being beaten ruthlessly by the...
 
Think you’re a Taboo champ? PROVE IT! Come with a team...
 
By: Kirsten John Foy Can you imagine needing a service with...
 
Last year thousands of MomsRising.org members told Governor Coumo that NY’s...
 
Natasha was on her way to the library when she was...
 
After a year of research and conversations with hundreds of local...
 
Last month on November 17, I gathered with about 40 other...
 
By YK Hong Dedicated to all of those who walk down...
 
By John Raskin Brooklynites are working together to win a better...
 
We have a short window of time to have a real...
 
Oliver S. talks about racial profiling in this sound bite about...
 
At  Save Our Streets  and  Crown Heights Community Mediation Center  our hearts go out to the town of Newtown,...
 
Listen to Oscar C. talk about his encounters with the NYPD...
 
Listen to Paulene J. talk about the time her grandson was...
 
By: Leon Johnson As a child the primary location of refuge,...
 
By: Byron Hurt The food we eat is as critically important...
 
Listen to Ricky S. talk about the misplaced priorities of the...
 
It was a moment many had expected for years, ever since...
 
Listen to Roland L. talk about how gay and queer people...
 
Listen to Roy F. talk about how the police can get...
 
In March, 2012, School District 16 in Bedford-Stuyvesant was identified in...
 
Here in Central Brooklyn, we’re pretty lucky. Sort of. Sure we...
 
Whatever your cultural or ethnic background, conversations inevitably turn to food...
 
In this podcast, hear Samuel break down the real issue of...
 
Although New York City public schools progress reports for academic year...
 
Rally Saturday, November 17 1pm Franklin Ave. & Park Pl., Brooklyn...
 
By Rachel M. Kleinman & Damon T. Hewitt Each year, nearly...
 
In light of all the inspiring work communities across the city...
 
Think Stop & Frisk is only a problem for men? Think...
 
The Brooklyn Movement Center has teamed up with the Brooklyn Community...
 
“Just because they have a badge or a uniform they think...
 
[UPDATE]  Brooklyn Community Foundation  is in the process of coordinating a recovery fund. Visit...
 
The  Center for Constituational Rights  has created a podcast of New Yorkers telling their stories...
 
This Wednesday, the Center for Constitutional Rights (CCR), fellow advocates, and...
 
Last week, MomsRising.org along with over a hundred New Yorkers rolled...
 
Wednesday, October 3rd at 6 p.m., Executive Director, Mark Winston Griffith...
 
Today, Communities United for Police Reform (CPR), partner orgnaizations, including BMC,...
 
I’m a committed New York sports fan. More importantly, I’m a...
 
On this one year anniversary of the birth of Occupy Wall...
 
For years, the Heatwave barbeque in Prospect Park was a huge...
 
The security guards at New York City Hall were overwhelmed, not...
 
In Gwen Guthrie’s 1986 hit “Ain’t Nothing Going On But The Rent” she...
 
<a href=”http://brooklynmovementcenter.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/dnainfo.jpg”><img class=”size-medium wp-image-409″ src=”http://brooklynmovementcenter.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/dnainfo-300×224.jpg” alt=”Bk stoop” width=”300″ height=”224″ /></a> BK...
 
<strong>By Lindsay Kalter</strong> <a href=”http://brooklynmovementcenter.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/photoadayintersections.jpg”><img class=”size-medium wp-image-417″ alt=”photo a day garden”...
 
The Brooklyn Movement Center believes everyday people are the true witnesses...
 
On the Block with BMC is a monthly video series profiling...
 
We have an office! We have an office! For almost 4...
 
The Brooklyn Movement Center believes everyday people are the true witnesses...
 
2013 will be a defining moment for public education. Why, you...
 
Are you going to be a high school junior or senior...
 
A tiny burst of energy is enough to get any ball...
 
  Please come out and check out this important film being...
 
Daily Press , a coffee shop on Franklin & Hancock in Bedford-Stuyvesant, is...
 
By now, we’ve all heard about  Trayvon  Martin. The  unarmed, seventeen year old kid  killed while going...
 
By Maitefa Angaza – The Pratt Center for Community Development, Pratt’s Initiative...
 
Our very own Mark Winston Griffith was on NPR with Brian...
 
Several stores in the Bed-Stuy community have a new product on...
 
Over 150 Frederick Douglass Academy IV (FDA IV) and P.S. 26 parents, alumni,...
 
Executive Director Mark Winston Griffith joined Arva Rice, the president and CEO...
 
There are a lot of reasons for Central Brooklynites to not get involved...
 
You know Mary Ward.  She is in all of our families....
 
A lot of attention has been paid recently to the rise...
 
Shhhh!  Don’t tell anyone!  There was an election just a few...
 
“Get on the bus!” That was my clarion call for the past...
 
In partnership with 500 Men Making a Difference, and the administration...
 
New details are emerging on the Department of Education’s decision that...
 
Is it a stay of execution or a permanent reprieve? After...
 
With Cathie Black’s departure, the public’s focus will remain on the...
 
After only a few short months on the job, Cathie Black...
 
Elliot Vazquez, a junior at Samuel Gompers High School in the...
 
In March, the New York Police Department released its stop-and-frisk numbers...
 
They’re super schools sent to save America’s neediest children.  Or they’re...
 
Congressman Anthony Weiner recently  released a report   that found that since 2006, the...
 
Robert G. Thompson is a multimedia journalist, writer, and filmmaker, keeping...
 
The state and city budgets contain nothing but bad news for...
 
Two years ago, Boys and Girls High School got a D...
 
Today on our website, the MC’s journalism intern Patrick Wall sounds...
 
Robert G. Thompson is a multimedia journalist, writer, and filmmaker, keeping a regular...
 
“I love the concept of change. Everybody’s in favor of change....
 
Robert G. Thompson is a multimedia journalist, writer, and filmmaker, keeping a regular...
 
The District 16 Project Bed-Stuy Patch/C.Zawadi Morris November 6, 2012  ...
 
Last week Bronx Borough President Ruben, NYC Comptroller John Liu, several...
 
Among the many items in this week’s news, there was one...
 
When times are hard, you discover who your real friends are....
 
The recent news that Mayor Bloomberg offered Jeffrey Canada, the founder...
 
It’s no secret that Central Brooklyn is a poster child for...
 
Check out this  article in The Root , written by the Executive Director of the...
Originally written for Gawker . With Brooklyn’s spring thaw in full effect,...